Indirect speech: questions and answers
Word order: I asked where Alice was.
In reported questions the subject normally comes before the verb in standard English, and auxiliary do is not used.
DIRECT:
Where’s Alice?
INDIRECT:
I asked where Alice was. (not usually … where was Alice.)DIRECT:
When are you leaving?
INDIRECT:
He wanted to know when I was leaving. (not usually … when was I leaving.)DIRECT:
What do I need?
INDIRECT:
She asked what she needed. (not… what did she need.)DIRECT:
Where are the President and his wife staying?
INDIRECT:
I asked where the President and his wife were staying. (notWhere were staying …)
The same structure is used for reporting the answers to questions.
- I knew how they felt. (not
… how did they feel.) - Nobody told me why I had to sign the paper. (not
… why did I have to sign …) - She explained what the problem was.
- They haven’t told me where I’m going to work.
In very informal speech, indirect questions sometimes have the same word order as direct questions:
- He asked when was I leaving.
- We’re wondering will we get to Cardiff on time, will we be able to park.
No question marks
Question marks are not used in reported questions.
- We asked where the money was. (not
… where the money was?)
yes/no questions: He asked if …
Yes/No questions are reported with if or whether (for the difference, (see here).
- The driver asked if/whether I wanted the town centre.
- I don’t know if/whether I can help you.
In reported questions, we do not use a present tense after if to talk about the future.
- I’m not sure if I’ll see her tomorrow. (not
… if I see her tomorrow.)
say and tell: answers, not questions
Say and tell are not used to report questions.
- not
The driver said whether I wanted the town centre.
But say and tell can introduce the answers to questions.
- Please say whether you want the town centre.
- He never says where he’s going.
- I told her what time it was.
note
For the difference between say and tell, (see here).